The DiveMon, Nov 16 · Nvidia earnings is Tue, Nov 17 · After the close (about 3:20 PM CT)

Nvidia reports Tuesday: what happened the last two times it reported into a falling Nasdaq, with the Fed paused after a hike

The story behind the headline: what happened, why it happened, and what it meant for your money.

← All dives

History, not a prediction. Commentary and education only. Not financial advice.

On Tuesday after the closing bell, Nvidia reports its quarterly results. It's one of the biggest companies in the S&P 500 and the face of the AI boom, so its numbers move far more than one stock. And this one lands at a tense moment. The Fed (the Federal Reserve, the central bank that sets the cost of borrowing) raised interest rates in September, then held steady in October. AI and chip stocks have been sliding: the Nasdaq is more than 10% below its October record, which puts it in a correction, Reuters reported on Monday.

We've been here before. Twice, in 2024, Nvidia reported while the Fed was on hold after its last hike and the Nasdaq had been falling going in. Each time, we followed what happened at the kitchen table, in the markets, and in a typical retirement account, from a week before the report to months after.

Both times, Nvidia beat expectations. The reaction was the opposite. Here's why.

Nvidia earnings reports where the Fed was holding rates steady and its last move had been a hike, and the Nasdaq Composite fell over the five trading days going into the report (from the close five sessions before the report to the close on report day). In our record, which starts in 2021, that picks two reports. Nothing else was considered.

How to read the $10,000 chart: each line shows what $10,000 in a fund that tracks the S&P 500 (the kind found in many 401(k)s) did, starting one week before the report. Nvidia reports after the close, so "report day" here is the next trading day, when the market first reacts. It's an illustration of how the index moved, not a return anyone earned; fund fees and dividends aren't included.

February 2024: "Nvidia beat. The market partied."

$10,000 · Feb. 2024
$9.5k$9.75k$10k$10.25k$10.5k$10.75k$11kStartDay beforeReportWeekMonth3 mo

At the kitchen table

In the week before the Feb. 21, 2024 report, a gallon of regular gas averaged about $3.27. A new 30-year mortgage carried a 6.77% rate. Short-term savings paid well: the 3-month Treasury bill rate, a rough guide to what new savings accounts and CDs (certificates of deposit) can pay, was about 5.2%. The latest unemployment rate out at the time, January's, was 3.7%.

The scene

The Fed had last raised rates in July 2023, to a top of 5.50%, and had held there since. The question in early 2024 wasn't another hike, it was when the first cut would come. Investors were betting on June, Reuters reported the day after the report.

Going in, the Nasdaq had slipped about half a percent over the five sessions before the report. The fear gauge (the VIX, which tracks how big a move traders expect) was near 15. That's calm. Our $10,000 in an S&P 500 fund was at about $10,060 the day of the report.

What came out

Nvidia's revenue for the quarter was $22.1 billion, above the $20.62 billion analysts expected, according to LSEG data cited by CNBC. More important to investors, it forecast about $24 billion for the next quarter, above the $22.17 billion analysts expected, according to LSEG data cited by Reuters. That forecast pointed to roughly three times the revenue of a year earlier, driven by demand for its AI chips, Reuters reported.

Why markets reacted the way they did

Investors bought growth and tech stocks after the results eased fears of a sharp tech selloff, Reuters reported. Nvidia cleared a high bar by a wide margin, and the relief spread to everything tied to AI.

Nvidia jumped 16.4% the next day, adding a record $277 billion in market value, Reuters reported. The S&P 500 rose 2.11% to a record close and the Nasdaq rose 2.96%, according to Reuters. Our $10,000 ended report day at about $10,270.

"As Nvidia goes, so goes the world," he told Reuters.Jack Janasiewicz, Natixis Investment Managers Solutions

What happened next

A week later: about $10,290. The rally held.

A month later: about $10,570. Stocks kept climbing into spring.

Three months later: about $10,710. The Fed was still on hold, and the first cut was further off than traders had bet in February: it didn't come until September 2024, according to our record. (Plenty happened over three months besides this report.)

What it meant for your money

For investors in a broad index fund, the report day was a strong one. It also showed how much of the market now rides on one company: a single earnings report moved the whole S&P 500 by 2%. For borrowers and savers, not much changed: mortgage rates stayed near 7% and short-term savings kept paying above 5%.

August 2024: "Nvidia beat. The stock fell anyway."

$10,000 · Aug. 2024
$9.5k$9.75k$10k$10.25k$10.5k$10.75k$11kStartDay beforeReportWeekMonth3 mo

At the kitchen table

In late August 2024, gas was about $3.31 a gallon. Mortgage rates had been easing: the 30-year rate was 6.46%. Short-term savings still paid about 5%. The latest unemployment rate out at the time, July's, was 4.2% (as since revised), up from 3.7% at the start of the year.

The scene

The Fed's last move was still the July 2023 hike, and it had held since. But by August 2024, the conversation had turned to cuts: the Fed had signaled it planned to start cutting, and traders expected the first cut in September, AP reported. In July, Fed Chair Jerome Powell had said a cut could be on the table as early as September if inflation kept falling, Reuters reported.

The mood going in was jumpier. Tech stocks had been shaky, and the Nasdaq had fallen about 2% over the five sessions before the report. Our $10,000 was at about $9,950 the day of the report.

What came out

Nvidia's revenue was $30.04 billion, above the $28.42 billion analysts expected, according to Zacks. It forecast $32.5 billion for the next quarter, above the $31.77 billion average from LSEG, Reuters reported. It also announced a $50 billion stock buyback.

Why markets reacted the way they did

Nvidia's stock had risen more than 150% that year going in, and its profit-margin forecast came in slightly below estimates, Reuters reported. This time, a beat wasn't enough. Investors were used to blowouts, and a smaller one read as a letdown.

The beat was much smaller than recent ones, and the bar was set "a tad too high," he told Reuters.Ryan Detrick, Carson Group

Nvidia fell 6.4% the next day, AP reported. But the rest of the market didn't follow it down: a report that morning revised second-quarter economic growth up to 3%, AP reported. The S&P 500 ended roughly flat and the Nasdaq fell 0.2%, while the Dow hit a record. Our $10,000 ended report day at about $9,950, unchanged.

What happened next

A week later: about $9,620. Stocks fell in early September before recovering.

A month later: about $10,250. On Sept. 18, the Fed cut rates for the first time since 2020, according to our record, and stocks recovered.

Three months later: about $10,670. The Fed cut again in November. (Same caveat as before: plenty happened besides this report.)

What it meant for your money

Borrowers got relief in the months that followed: the 30-year mortgage rate fell to 6.08% by late September, before rising again to 6.81% by late November. Savers saw short-term rates start to come down after the cuts. For a long-term investor, Nvidia's drop was a bad day for one stock, not for the whole market.

What was similar, what was different

Feb. 2024Aug. 2024This week
Fed's last moveHiked July 2023, then heldHiked July 2023, then heldHiked Sept. 16, held Oct. 28
Fed's key rate (top of range)5.50%5.50%4.00%
What traders were bettingFirst cut by mid-2024First cut in SeptemberA December hike, fully priced (CME FedWatch, via Reuters)
Nasdaq going inDown about 0.5% over five sessionsDown about 2% over five sessionsIn a correction, more than 10% below its record (Reuters)
Latest unemployment rate out3.7% (Jan.)4.2% (July, as revised)4.1% (Oct.)
Gas, per gallon$3.27$3.31$4.00
30-year mortgage6.77%6.46%7.11%
What short-term savings paidabout 5.2%about 5.0%about 4.1%
Revenue expected$20.62B (LSEG)$28.42B (Zacks)About $109.1B (analysts, via Reuters)

What was similar

  • The Fed was on hold after a hike. Each time, its last move had been an increase, and it was waiting.
  • The Nasdaq was falling going in. Investors came into each report nervous about tech.
  • Nvidia beat. Both times, revenue and the next-quarter forecast came in above what analysts expected.

What was different

  • Which way the Fed was leaning. In 2024, the next move everyone expected was a cut. This week, traders expect another hike.
  • How high the bar was. In February 2024, a big beat surprised people. By August 2024, big beats were expected, so a smaller one disappointed.
  • The size of the drop going in. This week's slide is much deeper: the Nasdaq is in a correction. And this is Nvidia's first report since its CEO resigned last week; interim CEO Colette Kress is set to speak after the results, AP reported.

Same setup, opposite days. Why?

Two beats, two very different next days. Here's what made the difference.

1. Markets react to the surprise, not the result. In February 2024, Nvidia beat by a wide margin that most people hadn't expected. In August 2024, the beat was smaller than investors had grown used to. Good numbers that fall short of hopes can still send a stock down.

2. The forecast matters as much as the quarter. Both times, investors focused on what Nvidia said about the next three months. In February, the forecast was a blowout. In August, it beat, but by less, and the profit-margin outlook came in a touch low.

3. One stock isn't the market. In February 2024, Nvidia carried the whole market to records. In August 2024, it fell 6% and the S&P 500 barely moved, because strong economic data the same morning pulled the other way.

Where they did rhyme: the months after

Three months after each report, our $10,000 was higher than where it started, as the bigger picture took over from any single company's results.

Our read, not a rule. Two cases can't prove a pattern, and the next one can always break it. This is how the chain has worked, not a prediction of how Tuesday will go.

Where Tuesday's report reaches your money

An earnings report doesn't change your bills that night. But it travels, and here's the path it has tended to take:

  1. The report shows whether Nvidia's sales and forecast beat what analysts expected, and by how much.
  2. The stock moves after hours, often within minutes, and other AI and chip stocks tend to move with it.
  3. The next morning, index funds feel it. Nvidia is one of the largest companies in the S&P 500, so a big move in its stock moves a typical 401(k) index fund too.
  4. What else happens that day matters. Economic data, the Fed and other news can amplify or offset the reaction.

The chain is how it has worked, not what will happen on Tuesday, and nothing here is a suggestion to do anything with your money.

Let's see what really happens.

We'll add the result here after the release, and file it in the record.

What really happened · added Tue, Nov 17, 2026 after the close

This release next to the cases above, from the record: expected vs actual, and how the S&P 500, Nasdaq and gold closed. Written with the same marks: facts cited, our read labeled.

This time

Tue, Nov 17, 2026 · After the close (about 3:20 PM CT)

Expected: added from a named poll (Reuters, Dow Jones, Bloomberg or FactSet) once it's published.

On Tuesday after the close, Nvidia reports. We'll be watching the next-quarter forecast first, then the after-hours move, then how the market opens Wednesday. We'll add what really happened right here, and in our Briefs.

By the Numbers: every number, chart and source behind the Dive, for those who want to check the math.

New to any of this? The Academy explains earnings, the Fed and interest rates from scratch.

Sources

How to read this:Reported factAnalyst viewOur read

The cases are picked by the rule above, nothing else. Past reactions don't tell you what happens next. Times are Central. Corrections are shown in the text and dated. Our standards

Get the Brief, free.

Before the news and after it, every trading day.

Subscribe free

Know what's true. Decide for yourself.

Get the Brief