History, not a prediction. Commentary and education only. Not financial advice.
The Dive tells the story of two Nvidia earnings reports that came while the Fed was on hold after a hike and the Nasdaq was falling going in: Feb. 21, 2024 and Aug. 28, 2024. This page shows the work: how we picked those two, how we measured them, every figure we used, and where each one comes from. If a number here disagrees with the Dive, the Dive is wrong and we fix it.
How we chose the cases
The rule: Nvidia earnings reports where the Fed was holding rates steady and its last move had been a hike, and the Nasdaq Composite fell over the five trading days going into the report (from the close five sessions before the report to the close on report day). Tuesday's report, Nov. 17, comes with the Fed holding after its Sept. 16, 2026 hike (it held on Oct. 28).
Our Nvidia record starts with the November 2021 report. Four reports came while the Fed was holding after a hike (its last move was the July 26, 2023 hike):
| Report | Nasdaq, five sessions going in | Picked? |
|---|---|---|
| Nov. 21, 2023 | +0.75% | No |
| Feb. 21, 2024 | −0.48% | Yes |
| May 22, 2024 | +0.35% | No |
| Aug. 28, 2024 | −2.03% | Yes |
Reports from 2021 to early 2022 came while the Fed was holding near zero after cuts, and reports from May 2022 to August 2023 came right after hikes, before any pause, so neither group fits. Nothing else was considered, and we didn't pick these because of how markets moved. Two cases are a small sample: enough to show how the chain has worked, not enough to prove a pattern.
How we measured
Daily closes come from the St. Louis Fed's FRED database. Nvidia reports after the close, so "T" is the next trading day, the first day the market can react.
- Before: the five trading days into the report, from the close six sessions before T (T−6) to the report-day close (T−1).
- Reaction day: the report-day close (T−1) to the close on T.
- After: the T close to the close five sessions later.
- The $10,000 lines: $10,000 placed in the S&P 500 at the T−6 close, then valued at each later close: $10,000 × (later close ÷ T−6 close). "A month later" is 21 trading days after T and "three months later" is 63. It's an illustration of how the index moved, not a return anyone earned; fund fees and dividends aren't included.
- Units: stock moves in percent; Treasury yields in basis points (bp), where 1 bp is a hundredth of a percentage point; the VIX in points.
- Forecasts: only from a named compiler (LSEG, Zacks), said case by case.
Case 1: Feb. 21, 2024 (Nvidia's fiscal fourth quarter 2024)
| Measure | Actual | Expected | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quarterly revenue | $22.10 billion | $20.62 billion | Nvidia; LSEG via CNBC (Reuters gives the estimate without naming a compiler) |
| Next-quarter revenue forecast | about $24.0 billion | $22.17 billion | Nvidia; LSEG via Reuters |
| Nvidia after hours | up about 10% | Reuters | |
| Nvidia, next-day close | +16.4% | Reuters |
Also: initial jobless claims unexpectedly fell (Reuters). Investors were betting the Fed's first rate cut would come in June (Reuters, Feb. 22); a day later, Reuters said a first cut was fully priced for July. Nvidia added a record $277 billion in market value on Feb. 22 (Reuters).
| How markets moved | Before (5 days) | Reaction day | After (5 days) |
|---|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 | +0.58% | +2.11% | +0.18% |
| Nasdaq Composite | −0.48% | +2.96% | +0.31% |
| 2-year Treasury yield | 0 bp | +5 bp | −5 bp |
| 10-year Treasury yield | +1 bp | +1 bp | −8 bp |
| VIX | −0.51 (to 15.34) | −0.80 | −1.14 |
The math (FRED closes): S&P 500 Feb. 13, 2024: 4,953.17 → Feb. 21: 4,981.80 → Feb. 22: 5,087.03 → Feb. 29: 5,096.27 → March 22: 5,234.18 → May 22: 5,307.01. Nasdaq: 15,655.60 → 15,580.87 → 16,041.62 → 16,091.92. 2-year: 4.64% → 4.64% → 4.69% → 4.64%. 10-year: 4.31% → 4.32% → 4.33% → 4.25%. VIX: 15.85 → 15.34 → 14.54 → 13.40.
$10,000 at the Feb. 13 close: $10,058 (Feb. 21), $10,270 (Feb. 22), $10,289 (Feb. 29), $10,567 (March 22), $10,714 (May 22).
Reuters' closing story had the S&P 500 up 2.11% to a record 5,086.94 and the Nasdaq up 2.96% to 16,041.62; FRED and AP have the S&P at 5,087.03 (Reuters' figure was unofficial).
Case 2: Aug. 28, 2024 (Nvidia's fiscal second quarter 2025)
| Measure | Actual | Expected | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quarterly revenue | $30.04 billion | $28.42 billion | Nvidia; Zacks via AP (Reuters had $28.70 billion, compiler not named) |
| Next-quarter revenue forecast | $32.5 billion (±2%) | $31.77 billion | Nvidia; LSEG via Reuters |
| Next-quarter adjusted gross margin | 75% (±0.5 point) | 75.5% | Nvidia; LSEG via Reuters |
| Stock buyback | $50 billion | Nvidia; Reuters | |
| Nvidia after hours | down about 4% (Reuters); our record lists −5% | Reuters; record | |
| Nvidia, next-day close | −6.4% | AP (our record still lists this as not confirmed) |
Also that morning: second-quarter GDP was revised up to 3% from 2.8% (AP, Commerce Department). Traders expected the Fed's first rate cut at its September meeting (AP).
| How markets moved | Before (5 days) | Reaction day | After (5 days) |
|---|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 | −0.51% | −0.00% (down 0.22 point) | −3.28% |
| Nasdaq Composite | −2.03% | −0.23% | −4.71% |
| 2-year Treasury yield | −9 bp | +4 bp | −21 bp |
| 10-year Treasury yield | +5 bp | +3 bp | −15 bp |
| VIX | +0.84 (to 17.11) | −1.46 | +6.73 |
The math (FRED closes): S&P 500 Aug. 21, 2024: 5,620.85 → Aug. 28: 5,592.18 → Aug. 29: 5,591.96 → Sept. 6: 5,408.42 → Sept. 30: 5,762.48 → Nov. 27: 5,998.74. Nasdaq: 17,918.99 → 17,556.03 → 17,516.43 → 16,690.83. 2-year: 3.92% → 3.83% → 3.87% → 3.66%. 10-year: 3.79% → 3.84% → 3.87% → 3.72%. VIX: 16.27 → 17.11 → 15.65 → 22.38.
$10,000 at the Aug. 21 close: $9,949 (Aug. 28), $9,949 (Aug. 29), $9,622 (Sept. 6), $10,252 (Sept. 30), $10,672 (Nov. 27).
AP's closing story had the S&P 500 down 0.22 point to 5,591.96 and the Nasdaq down 39.60 points (0.2%) to 17,516.43, matching FRED. Our record marks the S&P's percentage "not confirmed" because AP gave it as "less than 0.1%."
What came next: the Fed cut rates on Sept. 18, 2024, its first cut since 2020, and again on Nov. 7, 2024 (our Fed record).
Side by side
| Feb. 21, 2024 | Aug. 28, 2024 | This week (Nov. 17, 2026) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fed's key rate (top of range, FRED) | 5.50% | 5.50% | 4.00% |
| Fed's last move | Hike, July 26, 2023 | Hike, July 26, 2023 | Hike, Sept. 16, 2026 (held Oct. 28) |
| Revenue vs. expected | $22.10B vs. $20.62B | $30.04B vs. $28.42B | About $109.1B expected (analysts, via Reuters; no compiler named, so not used as the forecast) |
| Gas, regular, weekly (EIA via FRED) | $3.269 (Feb. 19) | $3.313 (Aug. 26) | $3.995 (Nov. 9) |
| 30-year mortgage (Freddie Mac via FRED) | 6.77% (Feb. 15) | 6.46% (Aug. 22) | 7.11% (Nov. 12) |
| 3-month Treasury bill (FRED) | 5.24% (Feb. 21) | 4.96% (Aug. 28) | 4.13% (Nov. 13) |
| Latest unemployment rate out (Labor Department via FRED, current figures) | 3.7% (Jan.) | 4.2% (July) | 4.1% (Oct.) |
| $10,000, three months after | $10,714 | $10,672 |
Later mortgage rates in the Dive: 6.08% (Sept. 26, 2024) and 6.81% (Nov. 27, 2024), Freddie Mac via FRED.
This week's context
- The Nasdaq is more than 10% below its Oct. 6, 2026 record close, which puts it in a correction (Reuters, Nov. 16).
- Markets fully price a quarter-point Fed hike in December (CME FedWatch, via Reuters, Nov. 16; Reuters' stories that day gave readings from 94% to 96%).
- Nvidia reports about 1:20 PM Pacific (about 3:20 PM Central) on Nov. 17 (Nvidia).
- Nvidia's CEO resigned last week; interim CEO Colette Kress is set to speak after the results (AP, Nov. 16).
Sources
- FRED, St. Louis Fed: SP500, NASDAQCOM, DGS2, DGS10, VIXCLS, GASREGW, MORTGAGE30US, UNRATE, DTB3, DFEDTARU (pulled Nov. 16, 2026)
- Nvidia: Q4 fiscal 2024 results
- Nvidia (SEC filing): Q2 fiscal 2025 results
- Reuters via Investing.com: Nvidia forecasts first-quarter revenue above estimates (Feb. 21, 2024)
- CNBC via NBC Chicago (Feb. 21, 2024)
- AP earnings snapshot via WTOP (Aug. 28, 2024)
- Reuters via Kitco: S&P 500, Dow jump to record closes as Nvidia sparks AI frenzy (Feb. 22, 2024)
- Reuters via Lincoln Daily News: Nvidia boom buoys stocks as Fed dampens rate-cut bets (Feb. 23, 2024)
- Reuters via BusinessDay: Nvidia shares fall as outlook fails to impress growth-hungry investors (Aug. 28, 2024)
- AP via ClickOnDetroit: Wall Street sees mixed results after late-day selling, drop for Nvidia (Aug. 29, 2024)
- Reuters via MarketScreener (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Reuters via Korea Times (Nov. 16, 2026)
- AP via Northern Virginia Daily (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Nvidia: conference call for third-quarter results
- Nvidia's past reports and Fed decisions: our Historical Data record, with its sources