The DiveMon, Nov 16 · Retail sales is Tue, Nov 17 · 7:30 AM CT

Retail sales Tuesday: what happened to your money the last two times the Fed paused right after a hike

The story behind the headline: what happened, why it happened, and what it meant for your money.

← All dives

History, not a prediction. Commentary and education only. Not financial advice.

On Tuesday morning, the government tells us how much Americans spent at stores, online and in restaurants in October. It's one of the freshest reads on how shoppers are doing, and this one lands at a touchy moment. The Fed (the Federal Reserve, the central bank that sets the cost of borrowing) raised interest rates in September, then held steady in October, with two officials voting for another hike. And after last week's hot inflation report, traders fully priced in a December hike, according to CME FedWatch, which tracks those bets, Reuters reported.

We've been here before. Twice in 2023, a retail sales report came out right after the Fed paused following a rate hike. Each time, we followed what happened at the kitchen table, in the markets, and in a typical retirement account, from a week before the report to months after.

Both times, shoppers beat expectations. The reaction was the opposite. Here's why.

The first retail sales report after a Fed meeting where it held rates steady right after raising them. In our record, which starts in 2021, that picks two reports. Nothing else was considered.

How to read the $10,000 chart: each line shows what $10,000 in a fund that tracks the S&P 500 (the kind found in many 401(k)s) did, starting one week before the report. It's an illustration of how the index moved, not a return anyone earned; fund fees and dividends aren't included.

June 2023: "Shoppers beat. Rates fell anyway."

$10,000 · June 2023
$9.5k$10k$10.5k$11kStartDay beforeReportWeekMonth3 mo

At the kitchen table

In the week before the June 15, 2023 report, a gallon of regular gas averaged about $3.60, down from about $5.01 a year earlier. Borrowing had gotten far more expensive: a new 30-year mortgage carried a 6.71% rate, up from 5.23% a year before.

Paychecks were ahead of prices. After adjusting for rising prices, the average hourly paycheck bought 0.2% more than a year earlier, the Labor Department reported. And short-term savings paid well: the 3-month Treasury bill rate, a rough guide to what new savings accounts and CDs (certificates of deposit) can pay, was about 5.1%.

The scene

The day before the report, the Fed held rates steady for the first time since it started raising them in March 2022. But it wasn't calling it a stop: its officials projected two more rate increases that year, Reuters reported. On the morning of the report, traders saw about a 72% chance of a hike in July, according to CME FedWatch, Reuters reported.

Investors were upbeat going in. In the week before the report, our $10,000 in an S&P 500 fund climbed to about $10,250. Wall Street's fear gauge (the VIX, which tracks how big a move traders expect) was near 14, which is calm.

What came out

Shoppers spent 0.3% more in May than in April. Economists polled by Reuters had expected a 0.1% decline. Cars and building materials led the way, Reuters reported.

Economists also watch a narrower number called the control group, which leaves out cars, gas, building materials and restaurants. Economists watch it as a steadier read on what households buy. It rose 0.2%, and April's figure was revised down to 0.6% from 0.7%.

One thing to know about retail sales: they aren't adjusted for inflation. A 0.3% rise in a month when prices rose too means people bought a little more, not 0.3% more stuff.

Why markets reacted the way they did

A stronger shopper usually means the Fed may need to keep rates higher. This time, another report that same morning pulled the other way. New claims for unemployment benefits stayed at 262,000, more than the 249,000 economists expected, Reuters reported. That helped fuel bets that the Fed wouldn't follow through with more hikes, Reuters said.

So short-term interest rates fell. (Specifically, the 2-year Treasury yield fell about 12 hundredths of a percentage point by the close; think of it as the market's running bet on where the Fed is headed.) The S&P 500 rose 1.22% and the Nasdaq 1.15%, both to their highest closes in about 14 months, Reuters reported. Our $10,000 ended report day at about $10,370.

Strong spending and softer job numbers on the same morning read as the soft landing everyone hoped for: an economy that slows enough to cool prices without a recession. Tunkel said the data had the makings of a soft landing, Reuters reported.Irene Tunkel, BCA Research

What happened next

A week later: about $10,190. Stocks gave back all of the jump and a bit more, and short-term rates crept back up.

A month later: about $10,670. The rally ran on into July.

Three months later: about $10,430. In between, the Fed did raise rates on July 26, as traders had bet. It turned out to be the last hike of that stretch: our record shows the Fed held from there until it cut in September 2024.

What it meant for your money

Borrowing kept getting more expensive after the July hike: the 30-year mortgage rate passed 7% in mid-August, reaching 7.23% by Aug. 24. For savers, short-term rates stayed above 5%. For investors, the report day was a good one, but the bigger story was a market that kept climbing while the Fed made its final move.

October 2023: "Shoppers beat. Rates jumped."

$10,000 · Oct. 2023
$9.5k$10k$10.5k$11kStartDay beforeReportWeekMonth3 mo

At the kitchen table

By mid-October 2023, gas was about $3.58 a gallon, down from about $3.87 a year earlier. Mortgages were the pain point: the 30-year rate was 7.57%, up from 6.92% a year before.

Paychecks were gaining ground. After adjusting for prices, the average hourly paycheck bought 0.5% more than a year earlier, the Labor Department reported. Short-term savings paid about 5.3%.

The scene

The Fed had raised rates in July 2023 to the highest level since 2001, AP reported, then held in September. Most of its officials still penciled in one more hike that year, CNBC reported in September. But traders didn't expect it soon: that day, they saw about a 90% chance the Fed would hold again on Nov. 1, according to CME FedWatch, CNBC reported.

The mood was tense. Worries about war in the Middle East had shaken markets, AP reported, and long-term interest rates had been climbing for weeks. In the week before the report, our $10,000 edged up to about $10,090. The fear gauge was near 17, a bit jumpier than in June.

What came out

Shoppers spent 0.7% more in September, more than double the 0.3% that economists polled by Reuters expected. August was revised up to 0.8% from 0.6%. The control group rose 0.6%, and August's was revised up too, to 0.2% from 0.1%. Spending at restaurants rose 0.9%, AP reported.

"The death of the US consumer has been greatly exaggerated."Omair Sharif, Inflation Insights (to Bloomberg)

Why markets reacted the way they did

This time, nothing in the morning's news pulled the other way. A strong shopper pushed against the market's bet that the Fed was done.

Short-term interest rates jumped. The 2-year Treasury yield hit its highest level since 2006 during the session, CNBC reported. The 10-year yield, which mortgage rates tend to follow, rose about 12 hundredths of a percentage point to about 4.83%.

Stocks didn't fall much that day: the S&P 500 closed essentially flat and the Nasdaq fell 0.25%, Reuters reported. Tech had its own problem: Nvidia fell 4.7% after the U.S. moved to block more advanced computer chips from going to China, AP reported. Our $10,000 ended report day at about $10,090, unchanged.

What happened next

A week later: about $9,800. Long-term rates kept climbing: two days after the report, the 10-year yield reached 4.98%, and stocks slid about 3% over the week.

A month later: about $10,390. On Nov. 1, the Fed held again, leaving the door open to more increases, Reuters reported. The extra hike never came.

Three months later: about $11,030. In December, the Fed held once more, and 17 of its 19 officials projected lower rates by the end of 2024, Reuters reported. Stocks rallied hard into the new year. (Same caveat as before: plenty happened over three months besides this report.)

What it meant for your money

Borrowers felt it first. The 30-year mortgage rate rose to 7.79% by Oct. 26, then fell back to 6.61% by the end of December as long-term rates came down. Savers kept earning above 5% on short-term savings. For a long-term investor, the scary week after the report turned out to be a dip, not a turning point.

What was similar, what was different

June 2023Oct. 2023This week
Fed's last movesHiked May 3, held June 14Hiked July 26, held Sept. 20Hiked Sept. 16, held Oct. 28
Fed's key rate (top of range)5.25%5.50%4.00%
What traders were betting (CME FedWatch)About 72% chance of a July hikeAbout 90% chance of no change Nov. 1December hike fully priced (Nov. 10)
Unemployment (as revised)3.7% (May)3.8% (Sept.)4.1% (Oct.)
Gas, per gallon$3.60$3.58$4.00
30-year mortgage6.71%7.57%7.11%
What short-term savings paidabout 5.1%about 5.3%about 4.1%
Paychecks vs. prices (past year)+0.2% (May)+0.5% (Sept.)-0.7% (Sept.)
Market moodCalm, rallyingTense, rates climbingJumpy after a tech selloff

What was similar

  • The Fed was at the same moment. Each time, it had just paused after raising rates and was deciding, report by report, whether one more hike was needed.
  • Shoppers beat expectations. Both reports came in well above what economists polled by Reuters expected, and the control group rose too.
  • Savers were earning something. Short-term savings paid roughly 4% to 5.3% in all three periods.

What was different

  • The kitchen table. In 2023, gas was cheaper than a year earlier and paychecks were starting to beat prices. This week, gas is about 94 cents higher than a year ago and paychecks are still falling behind prices.
  • What traders were betting. In June 2023 they expected another hike; in October 2023 they expected the Fed to stay put. This week, a December hike is already fully priced, and after last week's inflation report, traders started to price some chance of a bigger, half-point move, Reuters reported.
  • Where rates started. The Fed's key rate was above 5% in 2023. It's 4% now.

Same setup, opposite days. Why?

Two strong reports, two very different report days. Here's what made the difference.

1. Markets react to surprises against what they already expect. In June 2023, a July hike was already the base case, so a strong shopper didn't change much. In October 2023, traders were betting the Fed was done, so a strong shopper pushed directly against that bet, and short-term rates jumped.

2. Retail sales rarely arrive alone. In June 2023, the jobless claims report the same morning, and a rate hike from the European Central Bank, pulled attention away from shoppers. In October 2023, nothing offset the spending numbers.

3. The backdrop set the tone. June 2023 was calm and rallying. October 2023 already had rising long-term rates and a war in the Middle East. A beat in a tense market added to the strain.

Where they did rhyme: the months after

In both cases, the "one more hike" question got settled within a few months. After the June 2023 report, it came once, in July, and never again. After the October 2023 report, it never came at all. And three months after each report, our $10,000 was higher than where it started, as the bigger picture took over from any single report.

Our read, not a rule. Two cases can't prove a pattern, and the next one can always break it. This is how the chain has worked, not a prediction of how Tuesday will go.

Where Tuesday's report reaches your money

A retail sales report doesn't change your bills that morning. But it travels, and here's the path it has tended to take:

  1. The report shows whether shoppers spent more or less than expected, especially in the control group.
  2. Expectations for the Fed shift. Strong spending can keep prices rising, which raises the odds of more rate hikes; weak spending lowers them. This time, a December hike is already expected, so the question is how big and how many.
  3. Interest rates move, often within minutes, and over the following weeks that flows into mortgages and car loans (which tend to follow longer-term rates), credit cards (whose rates usually follow the Fed's key rate), and savings accounts and CDs (which tend to pay more when short-term rates rise).
  4. Stock prices react, and what else happens that day can matter as much as the report itself.

The chain is how it has worked, not what will happen on Tuesday, and nothing here is a suggestion to do anything with your money.

Let's see what really happens.

We'll add the result here after the release, and file it in the record.

What really happened · added Tue, Nov 17, 2026 after the close

This release next to the cases above, from the record: expected vs actual, and how the S&P 500, Nasdaq and gold closed. Written with the same marks: facts cited, our read labeled.

This time

Tue, Nov 17, 2026 · 7:30 AM CT

Expected: added from a named poll (Reuters, Dow Jones, Bloomberg or FactSet) once it's published.

On Tuesday at 7:30 AM Central, the October report comes out. We'll be watching the control group first, then short-term interest rates, then what else lands that day: Nvidia reports its results after the close. We'll add what really happened right here, and in our Brief that morning.

By the Numbers: every number, chart and source behind the Dive, for those who want to check the math.

New to any of this? The Academy explains spending, the Fed and interest rates from scratch.

Sources

How to read this:Reported factAnalyst viewOur read

The cases are picked by the rule above, nothing else. Past reactions don't tell you what happens next. Times are Central. Corrections are shown in the text and dated. Our standards

Get the Brief, free.

Before the news and after it, every trading day.

Subscribe free

Know what's true. Decide for yourself.

Get the Brief