By the Numbers

By the Numbers: Retail sales after a Fed pause

Every number, chart and source behind the Dive, for those who want to check the math.

← Back to the Dive: Retail sales Tuesday: what happened to your money the last two times the Fed paused right after a hike

History, not a prediction. Commentary and education only. Not financial advice.

The Dive tells the story of two retail sales reports that landed right after the Fed paused following a rate hike: June 15, 2023 and October 17, 2023. This page shows the work: how we picked those two, how we measured them, every figure we used, and where each one comes from. If a number here disagrees with the Dive, the Dive is wrong and we fix it.

How we chose the cases

The rule: the first retail sales report after a Fed meeting where it held rates steady right after raising them. Tuesday's report, Nov. 17, is the first since the Oct. 28, 2026 hold, which followed the Sept. 16, 2026 hike.

Our record starts in 2021. In our Fed record, three meetings were holds that came right after a hike: June 14, 2023, Sept. 20, 2023 and Oct. 28, 2026. The last one is this week's setup, so the rule picks exactly two past reports:

ReleaseReportWhere the Fed was
June 15, 2023May retail salesFirst report after the June 14, 2023 hold, which followed the May 3, 2023 hike
Oct. 17, 2023September retail salesFirst report after the Sept. 20, 2023 hold, which followed the July 26, 2023 hike

Nothing else was considered, and we didn't pick these because of how markets moved. Two cases are a small sample: enough to show how the chain has worked, not enough to prove a pattern.

How we measured

Daily closes come from the St. Louis Fed's FRED database. "T" is the release day.

  • Before: the five trading days into the release, from the close six sessions before (T−6) to the close the day before (T−1).
  • Release day: the close the day before to the close on release day.
  • After: the release-day close to the close five sessions later.
  • The $10,000 lines: $10,000 placed in the S&P 500 at the T−6 close, then valued at each later close: $10,000 × (later close ÷ T−6 close). "A month later" is 21 trading days after the release and "three months later" is 63. It's an illustration of how the index moved, not a return anyone earned; fund fees and dividends aren't included.
  • Trading days: days with an S&P 500 close in FRED. Market holidays (June 19 and July 4, 2023; Sept. 4, Nov. 23 and Dec. 25, 2023; Jan. 1 and Jan. 15, 2024) are skipped. When the bond market was closed but stocks traded (Oct. 9, 2023, Columbus Day), Treasury yields use the last close before it (Oct. 6, 2023).
  • "A typical day's move": a rule of thumb that divides the VIX by 16 to estimate a normal one-day move in the S&P 500. It's an estimate, not a forecast.
  • Units: stock moves in percent; Treasury yields in basis points (bp), where 1 bp is a hundredth of a percentage point; the VIX in points.
  • Forecasts: only from a named poll (Reuters poll; Dow Jones via CNBC), said case by case.

Case 1: June 15, 2023 (May retail sales)

MeasureActualForecastSource
Headline, month+0.3%−0.1%Reuters poll (Refinitiv's survey, per CNN, also −0.1%)
Excluding autos, monthnot confirmednot confirmed
Control group, month+0.2%not confirmedReuters ("core retail sales"); Bloomberg
April control group, revised0.6% (from 0.7%)Reuters

Also that morning: initial jobless claims 262,000 vs 249,000 forecast (Reuters); the European Central Bank raised rates to 3.5%, a two-decade high (Reuters). The day before, the Fed held at 5.00–5.25% and its officials projected two more increases that year (Reuters). Traders saw about a 72% chance of a July hike, up from about 60% the day before, according to CME FedWatch (Reuters, before the open).

How markets movedBefore (5 days)Release dayAfter (5 days)
S&P 500+2.46%+1.22%−1.75%
Nasdaq Composite+3.98%+1.15%−2.11%
2-year Treasury yield+18 bp−12 bp+9 bp
10-year Treasury yield+4 bp−11 bp+2 bp
VIX−0.06 (to 13.88)+0.62−1.06

The math (FRED closes): S&P 500 June 7, 2023: 4,267.52 → June 14: 4,372.59 (before: 4,372.59 ÷ 4,267.52 − 1 = +2.46%) → June 15: 4,425.84 (day: +1.22%) → June 23: 4,348.33 (after: −1.75%). Nasdaq: 13,104.89 → 13,626.48 → 13,782.82 → 13,492.52. 2-year: 4.56% → 4.74% → 4.62% → 4.71%. 10-year: 3.79% → 3.83% → 3.72% → 3.74%. VIX: 13.94 → 13.88 → 14.50 → 13.44.

Reuters' closing story had the S&P 500 up 1.22% to 4,425.84 and the Nasdaq up 1.15% to 13,782.82, both at their highest closes in about 14 months, matching FRED. Reuters had the 2-year down 6.5 bp at the time it was written; FRED's end-of-day figure is −12 bp. We use FRED in the tables.

What came next: the Fed raised rates by a quarter point on July 26, 2023, to 5.25–5.50%, and then held until a cut on Sept. 18, 2024 (our Fed record).

Case 2: October 17, 2023 (September retail sales)

MeasureActualForecastSource
Headline, month+0.7%+0.3%Reuters poll (Dow Jones poll, per CNBC, also +0.3%)
Excluding autos, monthnot confirmednot confirmed
Control group, month+0.6%not confirmed (Bloomberg: "better than expected," no figure)Reuters ("core retail sales")
August headline, revised0.8% (from 0.6%)Reuters
August control group, revised0.2% (from 0.1%)Reuters
Restaurants, month+0.9%AP

Also that day: Nvidia fell 4.7% after the U.S. broadened limits on advanced chip sales to China (AP); the Philadelphia semiconductor index fell 0.8% (Reuters). Traders saw about a 90% chance of no change at the Nov. 1 Fed meeting, according to CME FedWatch (CNBC). The 2-year yield hit its highest level since 2006 during the session (CNBC).

How markets movedBefore (5 days)Release dayAfter (5 days)
S&P 500+0.88%−0.01%−2.87%
Nasdaq Composite+0.62%−0.25%−2.91%
2-year Treasury yield+1 bp+10 bp−17 bp
10-year Treasury yield−7 bp+12 bp0 bp
VIX−0.49 (to 17.21)+0.67+1.09

The math (FRED closes): S&P 500 Oct. 9, 2023: 4,335.66 → Oct. 16: 4,373.63 → Oct. 17: 4,373.20 → Oct. 24: 4,247.68. Nasdaq: 13,484.24 → 13,567.98 → 13,533.75 → 13,139.87. 2-year: 5.08% (Oct. 6) → 5.09% → 5.19% → 5.02%. 10-year: 4.78% (Oct. 6) → 4.71% → 4.83% → 4.83%. VIX: 17.70 → 17.21 → 17.88 → 18.97. The 10-year reached 4.98% on Oct. 19.

Reuters' closing story had the S&P 500 down 0.43 point (0.01%) to 4,373.20 and the Nasdaq down 0.25% to 13,533.75, matching FRED. CNBC had the 10-year up about 13 bp to 4.84% and the 2-year up 12 bp to 5.218% intraday; FRED's end-of-day figures are +12 bp to 4.83% and +10 bp to 5.19%. We use FRED in the tables.

What came next: the Fed held on Nov. 1, 2023, leaving the door open to more increases (Reuters), and again on Dec. 13, 2023, when 17 of 19 officials projected a lower rate by the end of 2024 (Reuters). It held until the Sept. 18, 2024 cut (our Fed record).

Side by side

June 15, 2023Oct. 17, 2023
Headline vs Reuters poll+0.3% vs −0.1%+0.7% vs +0.3%
Control group+0.2%+0.6%
Before: S&P 500+2.46%+0.88%
Release day: S&P 500+1.22%−0.01%
Release day: Nasdaq+1.15%−0.25%
Release day: 2-year yield−12 bp+10 bp
Release day: 10-year yield−11 bp+12 bp
After: S&P 500−1.75%−2.87%
VIX the day before13.8817.21
Typical day's move (VIX ÷ 16)about 0.9%about 1.1%

This week: VIX 19.30 on Nov. 13, 2026 (FRED), so a typical day's move of about 1.2% (19.30 ÷ 16 = 1.21).

The $10,000 lines

$10,000 in the S&P 500 at the close six trading days before each report (the chart beside the Dive).

Day beforeReport dayA week laterA month laterThree months later
June 2023$10,246$10,371$10,189$10,674 (July 18)$10,428 (Sept. 15)
Oct. 2023$10,088$10,087$9,797$10,386 (Nov. 15)$11,027 (Jan. 18, 2024)

The math, every point (S&P 500 closes from FRED; values rounded to the dollar):

June 2023, start June 7, 2023 at 4,267.52:

  • Day before, June 14: $10,000 × 4,372.59 ÷ 4,267.52 = $10,246.21
  • Report day, June 15: $10,000 × 4,425.84 ÷ 4,267.52 = $10,370.99
  • A week later, June 23: $10,000 × 4,348.33 ÷ 4,267.52 = $10,189.36
  • A month later, July 18: $10,000 × 4,554.98 ÷ 4,267.52 = $10,673.60
  • Three months later, Sept. 15: $10,000 × 4,450.32 ÷ 4,267.52 = $10,428.35

Oct. 2023, start Oct. 9, 2023 at 4,335.66:

  • Day before, Oct. 16: $10,000 × 4,373.63 ÷ 4,335.66 = $10,087.58
  • Report day, Oct. 17: $10,000 × 4,373.20 ÷ 4,335.66 = $10,086.58
  • A week later, Oct. 24: $10,000 × 4,247.68 ÷ 4,335.66 = $9,797.08
  • A month later, Nov. 15: $10,000 × 4,502.88 ÷ 4,335.66 = $10,385.69
  • Three months later, Jan. 18, 2024: $10,000 × 4,780.94 ÷ 4,335.66 = $11,027.02

Computed with code from FRED's SP500 series, pulled Nov. 16, 2026. There's no line for this week yet: its starting point is the Nov. 9, 2026 close (7,549.94), and the line begins once Tuesday's close is in.

The kitchen table, in numbers

The latest reading before each report, with the same week a year earlier.

June 2023Oct. 2023LatestSeries (source)
Regular gas, per gallon$3.60, week of June 12 (yr ago $5.01)$3.58, week of Oct. 16 (yr ago $3.87)$4.00, week of Nov. 9 (yr ago $3.06)GASREGW (Energy Information Administration)
30-year mortgage rate6.71%, June 8 (yr ago 5.23%)7.57%, Oct. 12 (yr ago 6.92%)7.11%, Nov. 12 (yr ago 6.24%)MORTGAGE30US (Freddie Mac)
Unemployment rate (as revised)3.7% (May)3.8% (Sept.)4.1% (Oct.)BLS seasonally adjusted series as revised (2024 revision); Oct. 2026 per AP
Fed's key rate, top of range5.25%5.50%4.00%DFEDTARU (Federal Reserve)
3-month Treasury bill rate (day before)5.10%5.34%4.14% (Nov. 12)DTB3 (Federal Reserve)
Real average hourly earnings, past year+0.2% (May)+0.5% (Sept.)−0.7% (Sept.)Labor Department

Exact weekly gas figures: $3.595 (June 12, 2023) vs $5.006 (June 13, 2022); $3.576 (Oct. 16, 2023) vs $3.871 (Oct. 17, 2022); $3.995 (Nov. 9, 2026) vs $3.056 (Nov. 10, 2025). "About 94 cents higher than a year ago" in the Dive: $3.995 − $3.056 = $0.939.

Mortgage rates after each report (MORTGAGE30US): June 2023 case: 7.09% Aug. 17 and 7.23% Aug. 24, 2023. October 2023 case: 7.79% Oct. 26 and 6.61% Dec. 28, 2023.

Why the September paycheck figure for this week: the Labor Department's October 2026 real earnings release (Nov. 10) left the over-the-year comparison blank and said comparisons from October 2025 to October 2026 aren't available, so September (−0.7%) is the latest.

Why mortgage rates "before" the report: Freddie Mac publishes on Thursdays, after the 7:30 AM CT retail report, so for the Thursday June 15, 2023 report we use the June 8 reading.

This week

The releaseOctober 2026 retail sales, Tue. Nov. 17, 7:30 AM CT (Census Bureau)
Named forecastNot yet confirmed. We'll add it once a named poll (Reuters, Dow Jones, Bloomberg or FactSet) is published.
The last report (Sept., released Oct. 15)Headline +0.8% vs +0.3% (Reuters poll); control group +0.1% vs +0.3% (record)
FedHiked 25 bp Sept. 16 to 3.75–4.00%; held Oct. 28 with two officials (Cook, Hammack) favoring another hike (record)
Fed betsAfter the Nov. 10 inflation report, traders fully priced a hike of at least 25 bp in December, and priced an 11.8% chance of 50 bp, according to CME FedWatch (Reuters)
Same dayNvidia reports quarterly results after the close (company)

The wider picture

The two cases are the closest matches. Here is every retail sales report in our Historical Data released while the Fed was holding after its last move, a hike, so you can see how much the release-day reaction varied. Figures are straight from the record; "not confirmed" means the record doesn't have a named forecast or a sourced close.

ReleasedReportHeadlineForecastSurpriseControl groupS&P 500NasdaqFed range
June 15, 2023May 2023+0.3%not confirmed §not confirmed §+0.2%not confirmed §not confirmed §5.00–5.25%
July 18, 2023June 2023+0.2%+0.5%Below+0.6%+0.7%+0.8%5.00–5.25%
Oct. 17, 2023Sept. 2023+0.7%+0.3%Above+0.6%not confirmed §not confirmed §5.25–5.50%
Nov. 15, 2023Oct. 2023−0.1%−0.3%Above+0.2%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%
Dec. 14, 2023Nov. 2023+0.3%−0.1%Above+0.4%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%
Jan. 17, 2024Dec. 2023+0.6%+0.4%Above+0.8%−0.6%−0.6%5.25–5.50%
Feb. 15, 2024Jan. 2024−0.8%−0.1%Below−0.4%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%
Mar. 14, 2024Feb. 2024+0.6%+0.8%Below0.0%−0.3%−0.3%5.25–5.50%
Apr. 15, 2024Mar. 2024+0.7%+0.3%Above+1.1%−1.2%−1.8%5.25–5.50%
May 15, 2024Apr. 20240.0%+0.4%Below−0.3%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%
June 18, 2024May 2024+0.1%+0.3%Below+0.4%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%
July 16, 2024June 20240.0%−0.3%Above+0.9%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%
Aug. 15, 2024July 2024+1.0%+0.3%Above+0.3%+1.6%+2.3%5.25–5.50%
Sept. 17, 2024Aug. 2024+0.1%−0.2%Above+0.3%not confirmednot confirmed5.25–5.50%

§ Filled on this page from named sources, not yet in the record: June 15, 2023 forecast −0.1% (Reuters poll), so Above; S&P 500 +1.22%, Nasdaq +1.15% (Reuters, matching FRED). Oct. 17, 2023: S&P 500 −0.01%, Nasdaq −0.25% (Reuters, matching FRED).

Gold on the case days, from the record: June 15, 2023, spot −0.6% to $1,931.29 (Reuters, 8:39 AM ET); Oct. 17, 2023, spot +0.18% to $1,923.70 after the report (Kitco).

The lingo

  • Retail sales: the Census Bureau's monthly estimate of what stores, online sellers and restaurants sold. It's in dollars and isn't adjusted for inflation, so rising prices alone can lift it.
  • Headline: the total, everything included.
  • Excluding autos: the total without car dealers and parts stores, whose sales swing a lot.
  • Control group ("core retail sales"): leaves out autos, gas stations, building materials and restaurants, to show the steadier trend in what households buy.
  • m/m: month over month, the change from the prior month.
  • Forecast, named poll: the median estimate from a survey of economists (Reuters poll, Dow Jones). We only use forecasts we can name.
  • Surprise (Above, Below, In line): how the headline came in against the named forecast.
  • Fed's key rate (federal funds rate): the interest rate the Fed sets, shown as a range; we show the top of it.
  • Hold (pause): a Fed meeting where it leaves rates unchanged.
  • 2-year Treasury yield: what the U.S. government pays to borrow for two years. It moves with expectations for the Fed, so it's the market's running bet on the Fed's next steps.
  • 10-year Treasury yield: the same for ten years; mortgage rates tend to follow it.
  • Basis point (bp): a hundredth of a percentage point. 25 bp = 0.25 point.
  • VIX: the Cboe Volatility Index, Wall Street's "fear gauge." It reflects how big a move traders expect in the S&P 500 over the next month.
  • CME FedWatch: a tool that turns futures prices into the market's odds of each Fed decision.
  • Nasdaq Composite: nearly every Nasdaq-listed stock; it leans heavily toward tech.
  • Real earnings: pay adjusted for inflation; negative means a paycheck buys less than a year earlier.

New to any of these? The Academy explains them from scratch.

Sources

Know what's true. Decide for yourself.

Get the Brief